• Everyone, please help make our jobs easier and choose the correct category. Thank you

working off clock (slow carriers)

FrogNet97

New member
So there is a regular carrier that I think is working off the clock. I'm debating on whether I should say anything since the carrier typically goes past eval time. They would be getting back at the office late evenings if they started exactly on time. I was told it was basically a big no-no but I feel like I would be throwing a good carrier under the bus.
Why would anybody care if they start early if they go past eval time anyways?
 
3 route office: Both of the other carriers start early every day, and the 3 subs all come in early and work off the clock. My opinion: Why say anything? Doesn't bother me that my entire office, other than myself, comes in early!
 
Working off the clock is illegal. Also, it does hurt our craft especially with regard to standards. Then, there is the on the job injury / incident that occurs while NOT on the clock. After that , there is the part on the 4240 where the reg. carrier signs and it states with words to the effect , " I certify that all entries are correct and accurate . " Now, for the reg. carrier, he / she is signing that his / her entries ONLY are correct. When a relief carrier works , he / she signs in the comment section and that signature acknowledges that his / her entries are correct. Either way, when an employee starts at 7:30 , for example, and WRITES 8:00 ( example starting time ) and clocks in at 8:00 , that employee has falsified documents.
 

Attachments

Our office allows us to start 15 minutes early. Some people start before that. Is it good that we all work for free? Nope. Does it matter in the grand scheme of things? Ehhh i am always torn on that. I see the points made about working off the clock but i am also not going to be the hand holding someone's head under water. If they need the early start to do their job so be it. The job is difficult. No need to further complicate it.

Now if you are being told you can't start early and they do then i might argue more because why can they have it and i can't? If it is just some hall monitor type b.s you do you i guess? I see people leaving their cars running without being behind the wheel. Do i run to management like a rat and tell them...? That is on them. They know the rules and the consequences and if they wanna take that chance so be it.

What goes around comes around.
 
Management may be allowing slower carriers to start early. It's management's prerogative to do that and their responsibility to address it if people are not following their directions. I don't get paid to do management's job for them, that's up to the cry baby clerks that love ratting on carriers.

Now falsifying a timesheet is a totally separate issue, even when directed to by management. These managers that tell people to start early but clock in at regular start time know what RRECS data recording entails and are being dishonest as hell. Imagine missing "scan" entries or loading time that should have been recorded as part of the evaluation. Not only could they screw their own paycheck up but every other carrier's paycheck that serves that route as well. Management will be 100% ok with your paycheck going down which is why we should do all we can to prevent that.

If this is an older carrier, has medical issues or simply another person getting crushed by an overburdened route then some assistance should be provided. I think if it were me I would delicately try to obtain more info either from management or that particular carrier. Then you could take the info to your rep and decide how to proceed. A little help from a sub or maybe a route adjustment could help them not work for free and stay with evaluated time.
 
Now falsifying a timesheet is a totally separate issue, even when directed to by management. These managers that tell people to start early but clock in at regular start time know what RRECS data recording entails and are being dishonest as hell.
I'm pretty sure that when management enters the time(s) into payroll, they TOO are to certify / validate that all of the entries are accurate. If management is aware of carriers working off the clock, management is also falsifying documents. FLSA requires that accurate recording of work hours be recorded even for salaried employees.
 
When RRECS was started we had to learn all about it all by ourselves, on our own time. Union had a website we can go to, seminars and tons of questions and calls to our local stewards, all on our own time. That's working off the clock and it was allowed so who wants to start caring now.
And as we all know, RRECS is working just fine for all of us.
 
The issue is this place lacks the !$#@#ING COMMON SENSE TO MAKE THINGS WORK.

Think about from this way. You have no subs and no RCA wants to work or has POV in area and you have appt at say 3pm. You usually get done around 245. Why can't you start early to make sure you can get to appt on time since no one is available???? GOD FORBID YOU CLOCK IN EARLY, you're PM gets put on YELLCON!!!!!!!! That's the issue there is NO COMMON SENSE!!!! Unlike city carriers, we can't take off early to go to afternoon appt.

What's the big freaking deal if you have to start once in a while for an obvious reason such as an appt no sub available to work. At least someone was @#$@#%ING WILLING TO WORK THE !@%$#ING ROUTE.
 
Last edited:
When RRECS was started we had to learn all about it all by ourselves, on our own time. Union had a website we can go to, seminars and tons of questions and calls to our local stewards, all on our own time. That's working off the clock and it was allowed so who wants to start caring now.
And as we all know, RRECS is working just fine for all of us.
I consider looking at this forum working off the clock. You think nurses, teachers.construction workers, ditch diggers spend any spare time whatsoever trying to get questions & issues answered about how they get paid like rural carriers do? Name me another occupation that has to navigate the myriad of innuendo about their job plus the treatment by their employer.
 
as long as the carrier is "clocking in", there is no problem.

if the carrier is working off the clock, then it is your responsibility as a fellow carrier to bring that to the carrier's attention. if you don't feel comfortable with that, then notify your steward...it is DEFINITELY his/her responsibility to put a stop to it.
 
I consider looking at this forum working off the clock. You think nurses, teachers.construction workers, ditch diggers spend any spare time whatsoever trying to get questions & issues answered about how they get paid like rural carriers do? Name me another occupation that has to navigate the myriad of innuendo about their job plus the treatment by their employer.
I consider having to do my own research on how to use a tool that my company handed me and told me to use or I will get written up or fired for working off the clock.
Just because the company changed the way they do something, shouldn't THEY pay me to learn it?
They taught me how to use a punch clock and how to write in our times on green cards on the clock, didn't they?
Shouldn't THEY teach me how to use the system correctly?
PO handed us a piece of paper and said 'these are the big scans you need to do daily, use them". That's it.
PM's and managers went to training for it on the clock, why shouldn't we?
What other worker's pay is broken down, second by second, at their job daily? Does UPS get paid by the foot walking to door or FedEx get paid by the second scanning a package?
Jesus, our union set up a 'how to' list on it's website but ONLY union members could even see it, even they made the non-union members fight to get answers on their own.
Nurses get training and schooling for EVERYTHING, ditch diggers get training on new machines, teachers get training on new systems, we did not get proper training on the new scanning/pay system the PO adopted. Then write me up, cut my pay, yell at me or fire me for not using right.
 
So every time the union goes into contract negotiations management looks at the 80,000 rural routes and they tally the hours actually worked, according to the 4240's. Then they say to the union, your membership is getting paid for far more hours than they actually worked yet you want more money. Not a good way to start contract negotiations every few years. Then if things end up in arbitration management presents those same numbers to an arbitrator and some standard or standards end up getting cut. It happens every time. Then everybody whines and says the union sucks. (they do but that's another story) Almost every time it happens it's because rural carriers have handed them the knife to do the cutting with. Standards have been cut at almost every contract that I remember. Your 4240 should be an accurate accounting of your actual hours. Working off the clock is the absolute worst thing rural carriers have ever done to themselves.
 
Working off the clock is illegal. Also, it does hurt our craft especially with regard to standards. Then, there is the on the job injury / incident that occurs while NOT on the clock. After that , there is the part on the 4240 where the reg. carrier signs and it states with words to the effect , " I certify that all entries are correct and accurate . " Now, for the reg. carrier, he / she is signing that his / her entries ONLY are correct. When a relief carrier works , he / she signs in the comment section and that signature acknowledges that his / her entries are correct. Either way, when an employee starts at 7:30 , for example, and WRITES 8:00 ( example starting time ) and clocks in at 8:00 , that employee has falsified documents.
This is true my friend, and most po mgmt are fully aware of it, allow it, and condone it on the sly.....its not right, however it is RAMPANT all throughout the po structure. It is simply one more way the po is ROBBING THE CARRIERS ACROSS THE COUNTRY...😐😐😐😐
 
This is true my friend, and most po mgmt are fully aware of it, allow it, and condone it on the sly.....its not right, however it is RAMPANT all throughout the po structure. It is simply one more way the po is ROBBING THE CARRIERS ACROSS THE COUNTRY...😐😐😐😐
Oh, I know . it's going on in my old office and it's rampant. But what management doesn't realize is that this practice also hurts THEIR budget hours. Because of the unrecorded work hours, it "looks like" the work is being accomplished in "X" amount of time or the time on paper which is not at all accurate. You get just one office where 14 carriers out of 20 are starting 30 minutes early , that's 7 hours JUST THAT DAY of unpaid and unaccounted for labor. 7 hours !!!! With one more hour you have an eight hour work day. And that 7 hours in one day multiplied by 6 days a week is 42 hours. Hmmmmmmm , isn't that the hour threshold for a route to become regular ? We get cheated WAY more than enough. Heck, we are getting cheated in ways we are not yet aware. We certainly do not need to aid and abet The PO in their shenanigans. If someone has an appointment they need to make or something like that, management CAN ( contrary to popular belief ) grant permission for that carrier to start early BUT that carrier must clock in at that early start time and record that early start time on the 4240.
 
I consider looking at this forum working off the clock. You think nurses, teachers.construction workers, ditch diggers spend any spare time whatsoever trying to get questions & issues answered about how they get paid like rural carriers do? Name me another occupation that has to navigate the myriad of innuendo about their job plus the treatment by their employer.
Nurses and teachers most certainly do. They have continuing education requirements for which they pay and do not get paid.
 
FrogNet97 -- Working off the clock - "Why would anybody care if they start early if they go past eval time anyways?"

-- I'll take a guess you were not around for the disastrous Arbitrator Wells' "Award" of 2002, which basically came about because of the USPS's complaining to the arbitrator about hours paid for but not worked ( aka the "bump" ) and providing data proving rural carriers had been working under evaluation for years - and still getting paid the full evaluation of the route. The "award" led to numerous changes in work standards - none of which were in favor of rural carriers. That is why you should care about someone "working off the clock."

-- Working off the clock is nothing new:

- Step 4 ( W-7 ) The Andrea B. Wilson letter of July 28, 2002 begins: It is imperative that managers not allow carriers to work "off the clock" and that all work hours performed by rural carriers be accurately recorded on PS Form 4240, Rural Carrier Trip Record. The actual work hours by each rural carrier must be accurate in order to comply with the Fair Labor Standards Act ( FLSA ).

- Step 4 ( W-8 ) 2.5 pages from a National Board meeting about - you guessed it - Working off the clock!

-- once aware of a carrier working of the clock, a local steward should speak with the carrier. If the carriers continues to work off the clock, the steward should approach manglement to ensure all work hours are being accurately recorded. Should manglement fail to take corrective action, the steward should file a grievance against management for allowing the carrier in question to work without compensation.

- Step 4 ( R-16 ) page 2, #9: Carriers should not be permitted or otherwise encouraged to work ":off the clock" All carrier time worked MUST be recorded on the PS Form 4240.

- The June 2011 issue of Steward Link: Working Off the Clock: It Must Stop!

- The May 2018 issue of the National Magazine featured "Working "Off the Clock" in the Question Box section.

- Back in April of 2021, someone posted at Rural Info: Management's failure to control workhours is at least a MOU 14 violation.

-- "neciat's" posting is a good example why some post offices can not hire additional clerks. Higher ups see clerk work, such as throwing parcels, is being done with the current number of clerks -- except local manglement failed to mention RCA's were help throw parcels ( even after "Dual Appoint" ended ).

-- You didn't mention the age of the carrier in question.

- Section 151.2 of the PO-603: If the weekly time required to serve the route consistently varies more than three hours, either below or in excess of the route's standard hours, managers should consider corrective action. ( no mention of what that "corrective action" might be ) Exceptions may be made for carriers 55 years of age or older and carriers who have served continuously for 25 years or more, provided that their conduct and efficiency are satisfactory. When it is demonstrated that a carrier 55 or over cannot confine total working time to 48 hours per week or less, the route will be adjusted. ( not really sure how that applies in the RRECS world where routes have grown way past 57 standard hours )

-- Or if the carrier has some ailments.
 
Nurses and teachers most certainly do. They have continuing education requirements for which they pay and do not get paid.
My sister was an RN for 50 yrs. I guarantee you she never spent 5 minutes looking up things in which her employer was trying to undercut her. I know she had to occasionally take those CE courses to maintain her certification. And you know what, whoopty fricken do. But never took a salary reduction her whole career.
 
Starting early shouldn't be an issue as long as the carrier writes down and clocks in the exact time that they start. This was a problem for as long as I worked in the rural craft and it seems to have continued. It only hurts the craft as a whole in the long run.
 
Back
Top